My American Idol Review Of Last Night's Show

 

Here's my review for last night's performance.

Keeping it simple.

 

I had very hig expectations for this show because I adore Elton John.

Even though I thought most of them performed well, no one blew me away,  I am making my picks for the night, but ...

• Favorite male singer - James Durban.
  

 

 
 
 

• Favorite female singer - Pia Toscano.

 

 

 

 

• Send home - Paul McDonald
  

 

and

 

Jacob Lusk.

 

 
 

Comments

[Marg]

I came home late from work tonight...was too tired to watch..and decided to watch it tomorrow night..
I love John Elton music..he's a favorite...
I'll check back tomorrow to see if you were right.

[Jillian]

Awwww, Beverly! I like both of the guys you'd like to send packing! LOL. That's okay, that is what makes the world go around...we all like different stuff!

I'd send home Stefano and Haley.

It was fun but I do miss Simon. He gave a good balance to the show!

I'm enjoying your reviews!

[Dana Strickland]

COMPLETELY AGREE!!!!!!!!!!!!! Although I love Scotty too!!!!!!!!!!

[Julie]

I'm with you on your picks too, But, my picks to go home are Paul and Naima, I just didn't like her putting that Reggae on Sir Elton, it just wasn't right. But, favorite as always is James also, Now to send my votes into my American Idol Pool I am in. have a great day!!

Julie

[Helen]

Love this post each week! Again, James rocked my boat! I believe Thea and Jacob need to leave, sooner than later. Paul isn't a strong performer and in my opinion, neither is Casey. Lauren, Stephano and Naima gave good performances. Scotty is going to have to break out of the country exclusive mode at some point or he is in danger of being voted off. Pia is unbelievable and as Jennifer L said last night, Haley's was the best performance of all. There you have it ... in my own little opinion.

[Laura Ingalls Gunn]

My daughter is a huge Casey and Paul fan. We adore Sir Elton too!

[victoria]

Love Elton...was disappointed with Naima's performance...I'll watch tonight to see how you did with your picks :)

[Penny @ The Comforts of Home and Lavender Hill Studio]

I am sending Niama and Paul home...thought I think Jacob will be in the bottom three...
Hugs,
Penny

[Balisha]

I think that Thea and Halley should go.Saying this...It's really hard to pick favorites this season. In my estimation...it's the best season for American Idol. I love the panel of judges. I couldn't picture Steven on the panel...but he's doing a great job...Balisha

[kathi]

Don't tell me I missed a show that featured Elton's music!!!!! ARRRRRRGH! Can I find a repeat somewhere??? Anywhere????

[Picket]

Hey girl...would you believe Bill and I watched that last night for the first time this year..It just doesn't seem to have the talent that it use to have a few years ago...just came by to say hello sweetie and hope you have a great weekend....Picket

[Jeanne]

After watching tonight's show I am sad to see the girls go home. However, someone has to go each week and the girls were very gracious. I love this show.
Love you, Jeanne

[Coralie Cederna Johnson]

I totally agree with your picks to stay and those to go home! (I also LOVE Scotty!)
It's a fun time of year for Idol!
Coralie

[laura lee]

i'm so behind on american idol. this is mostest helpful, thanks!!!

[Nerina]

Oh my gosh Beverly,

I am so on the same page with you...great pics...to stay and to go!!

[deidre]

Not Paul...I love him...he4's like a new Rod Stewart...